Short answer: car insurance in Youngstown, OH 44509 depends on your ZIP code, coverage level and driver/home profile. Compare free quotes from licensed partners in ~2 minutes. Local averages: get a quote for your exact rate.
Updated August 2026
ZIP 44509 · Youngstown, OH · Mahoning County
Ohio statewide average: ~$947/yr (NAIC, 2023).
FAQ
How much is car insurance in ZIP 44509?
Rates in 44509 (Youngstown, OH) depend on coverage and profile. Compare free car insurance quotes from licensed partners.
Is ZIP 44509 in Youngstown?
Yes — 44509 is in Youngstown, Mahoning County, OH.
Nearby ZIP codes